Pump Comparison

Pitot Tube Pump vs Multistage Centrifugal Pump

For high head at a low flow, both pump types can do the job. They build pressure in different ways, which changes the wear parts, the seal’s operating conditions and the running cost. Here is how they compare, and what EHIK’s replacement projects recorded.

Two blue EHIK pitot tube pumps with motors, valves and pipework in a site-installed package.
Two EHIK pitot tube pumps in a site-installed package.

Two Ways to Build Pressure

One Stage or Many.

The difference in design explains most of the differences in wear, sealing and control.

Multistage centrifugal pump

Several impellers sit in series on one shaft. Each stage adds part of the head, so a higher head needs more stages, more close clearances and a longer rotor.

Pitot tube pump

A rotating casing spins the liquid, and a stationary pickup tube turns its speed into pressure. One stage gives the full head, up to 1,050 m (3,445 ft) in the standard range, with no multiple impeller or diffuser stages.

Side by Side

How the Two Designs Compare.

The main design differences at a glance.

Swipe or use the arrows to view all columns.

Pump design comparison
FeatureEHIK pitot tube pumpMultistage centrifugal pump
StagesOne stage for the full headSeveral stages in series; the head rises with the number of stages
Main wear pointsPickup tube, rotor, mechanical seal and bearingsImpellers, wear rings, interstage bushings, balancing device, seals and bearings
Shaft sealOne mechanical seal at the low-pressure inletOne or two shaft seals; the pressure they see depends on the design and the balancing arrangement
Axial thrustLow; the load comes mainly from the inlet pressureNeeds a balance drum, balance disc or opposed impellers
Low-flow operationBuilt for low flow; the minimum continuous flow of the model is confirmed at selectionAt very low flow, it can run far from its best efficiency point, with more recirculation, heat and vibration
Flow range0.05–100 m³/h (approx. 0.22–440 US gpm)Also available for much larger flows
Liquid viscosityUp to 250 cSt (best below 100 cSt)Efficiency falls as viscosity rises

Recorded Replacement Results

What Changed After the Replacement.

Multistage pumps that EHIK pumps replaced, with the results from each project record.

Swipe or use the arrows to view all columns.

Multistage pump replacement results
ProjectChangeRecorded result
Kong 6 Well, Shunan Gas Mine · 2015Motor rating 90 kW (approx. 121 hp) to 45 kW (approx. 60 hp)39.5% less electricity for the same volume of gas-field water
Wei 001-H1 Well, Shunan Gas Mine · 2014Motor rating 90 kW (approx. 121 hp) to 45 kW (approx. 60 hp)23.5% less electricity per cubic meter (approx. 264 US gal) of gas-field water
Jing 4 Central Station, Shunan Gas MineMultistage pump replaced48.3% less electricity per 10,000 m³ (approx. 2.64 million US gal) of water
Bao 46 Well, Shunan Gas MineMotor rating 75 kW (approx. 101 hp) to 45 kW (approx. 60 hp)A smaller motor for the same operating requirements
Daqing methanol workshop · 2009Motor rating 30 kW (approx. 40 hp) to 15 kW (approx. 20 hp)Stable delivery after severe cavitation and loss of prime
Daqing synthetic ammonia workshop · 201075 kW (approx. 101 hp) multistage pump replacedMore than RMB 200,000 a year saved in electricity

Energy results are from site meter readings at each project.

See the Shunan Gas Mine replacements ↗

Reasons for a Replacement

Why Plants Replace a Multistage Pump.

These are the problems customers most often brought to EHIK.

Frequent maintenance

Worn stages, clearances and seals mean repeated overhauls and downtime.

Leakage and falling pressure

As parts wear, the pump starts to leak and can no longer hold the required pressure.

High energy use at low flow

A large multistage pump working at a small flow wastes power. The Shunan projects above show what a replacement recorded.

Cavitation and loss of prime

At the Daqing methanol workshop, the old pump often lost prime; the EHIK pump restored stable delivery.

A Fair Comparison

When a Multistage Pump Is Still the Better Choice.

Choose the pump that fits the operating requirements.

Larger flows

Above about 100 m³/h (440 US gpm), a multistage pump is usually the better choice.

Lower heads

The smallest EHIK series starts at about 40 m (approx. 131 ft) of head. Below that, a standard centrifugal pump is enough.

Viscous liquids

Above 250 cSt, the liquid is outside the pitot tube pump range. Consider a positive displacement pump.

Replacement FAQs

Planning the Change.

Send the liquid properties, pressure and flow. NPSHa, inlet pressure and discharge pressure make the proposal more accurate.

How much electricity can a replacement save?

At Shunan Gas Mine, replacements recorded 23.5%, 39.5% and 48.3% less electricity. For your site, EHIK compares measured power, volume pumped and running hours under the same operating conditions.

Can the new pump connect to my existing piping?

Yes. EHIK can make the pump flanges to match your existing piping, so the new pump connects to it. So far, every EHIK replacement project has matched the customer’s piping. The baseplate and drive are confirmed on site. Inlet and outlet directions can be turned to suit your piping, for example by 90° or 180°.

How efficient is a pitot tube pump?

Peak efficiency depends on the model. In EHIK’s model tables it ranges from about 38% to 65%. Compare the two pumps at your actual operating point, where a large multistage pump may be far from its best efficiency point.

How fast do I get a proposal?

We reply within 1 business day. After we receive your operating data, we send a quotation and technical proposal for a pump or pump set within 3 business days.

Replacing a Multistage Pump?

Send Us Your Operating Data. We’ll Compare.

Tell us the liquid, flow and pressure, and the problems you have with the current pump. EHIK checks whether a pitot tube pump fits and what it would change.

Send Your Flow and Head

Tell us the flow, head and liquid. We reply within 1 business day.
Only your name or company and your email are required.
Use the Full Inquiry Form

Selection & Performance Curves

A proposed pump matched to the required liquid and operating conditions.

Outline Drawings

Equipment dimensions for checking the layout and connections.

Technical Support

Help with operating conditions, the proposed pump and included equipment.